The Mediterranean diet, often lauded for its health benefits, has become a popular topic in the field of nutrition. This dietary pattern, rooted in the traditional eating habits of countries bordering the Mediterranean Sea, is not just a culinary delight but also a powerful tool for promoting heart health. This response will explore the key components of the Mediterranean diet, its impact on cardiovascular health, and how it compares to other dietary approaches.
Understanding the Mediterranean Diet
The term "Mediterranean diet" refers to the traditional dietary patterns of people living in the Mediterranean region, particularly the Greek isle of Crete more than half a century ago. It is characterized by a high intake of plant-based foods, a moderate intake of fish, and limited consumption of red meat and dairy.
Plant-Based Emphasis: The diet is primarily plant-based, featuring an abundance of fruits, vegetables, whole grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds.
Healthy Fats: Olive oil is a primary source of fat, with nuts and avocados as other "green light" fat sources.
Limited Animal Products: Meat and dairy are consumed in moderation.
Fish: Fish is consumed more regularly than red meat.
The Mediterranean Diet and Heart Health
The Mediterranean diet has been extensively studied for its impact on cardiovascular health, and the research consistently suggests that it offers significant protection against heart disease.
Reduced Risk of Heart Disease: Adherence to a Mediterranean-style diet is associated with a lower risk of heart disease, cancer, and overall mortality.
Lower Mortality: The difference in average age at death between those eating the least and the most Mediterranean may be on the order of two years.
Healthier Aging: The Mediterranean diet is associated with healthier aging and a lower risk of frailty.
Protection Against Leading Killers: A diet rich in whole plant foods and low in animal-fat consumption confers protection against many of our leading killers.
Artery Function: Olive oil is commonly used in the Mediterranean to dress vegetables and salads, beans and other legumes, so its consumption can be an indicator of a more traditional, healthier diet.
Impeded Artery Function: Palm oil, soybean oil, and sunflower oil can impede the arteries’ ability to relax and dilate normally.
Neutralization of Oil's Effects: Consuming extra-virgin olive oil with a salad as part of a balsamic vinaigrette was shown to neutralize the artery-impairing effects of the oil.
Olive Oil Benefits: Replacing about a teaspoon of butter, mayonnaise, margarine, or dairy fat with about a teaspoon of olive oil every day would be expected to lower heart disease risk by 5 to 7 percent.
Key Components for Cardiovascular Benefit
Research has pinpointed certain components of the Mediterranean diet that are particularly beneficial for heart health.
Fruits and Vegetables: Greater intake of fruits and vegetables is a key factor in the mortality benefit of the Mediterranean diet.
Reduced Meat Consumption: Reduced consumption of meat is also a factor in the mortality benefit.
Plant-Based Focus: The benefits of the diet appear to be primarily due to the added plant foods.
Nuts: Nuts are a "green light" source of fat, and have been shown to positively impact artery health.
In the PREDIMED study, participants were effectively randomized for about four years to either (1) switch from consuming about three tablespoons of half-virgin olive oil a day to four tablespoons of all-virgin olive oil, (2) go from eating about half an ounce of nuts a day to a whole ounce, or (3) pretty much continue their regular diet.
The results were published in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Olive Oil: A Closer Look
Olive oil is a staple of the Mediterranean diet, but its specific role in heart health warrants further examination.
Monounsaturated Fats: Olive oil is rich in monounsaturated fats, which are considered heart-healthy.
Better than Butterfat: Olive oil is better than butterfat, but no significant difference was found between olive oil and other oils.
Not all Olive Oil is Equal: The quality of olive oil can vary.
Extra Virgin Olive Oil: Extra-virgin olive oil, is less processed, and retains more of its beneficial compounds.
Comparing the Mediterranean Diet to Other Diets
The Mediterranean diet is often compared to other popular diets to understand its unique benefits and limitations.
Mediterranean Diet vs. Standard American Diet
Standard American Diet: The typical American diet, which is high in processed foods, saturated fats, and animal products, contrasts sharply with the Mediterranean diet.
Health Benefits: The Mediterranean diet is protective compared to the standard American diet.
Reversing Damage: The meat-sweet American diet can slowly damage your kidneys, forcing the kidneys into a state of hyperfiltration, but this can be reduced by moving toward a more plant-based diet.
Mediterranean Diet vs. Vegetarian Diet
Similarities: Both diets emphasize plant-based foods.
Vegetarians have three times the odds of having their diets rated as highly adherent in the classic Mediterranean diet scoring system, and vegans have more than thirty times the odds.
The traditional Mediterranean diet itself can be considered to be a “near-vegetarian diet”.
Differences: The Mediterranean diet includes fish and small amounts of meat and dairy, while vegetarian diets exclude meat.
LDL Cholesterol: A study found that both a low-calorie Mediterranean diet and a low-calorie vegetarian diet lead to the same amount of weight loss, but the vegetarian group edged out an advantage with a significant drop in LDL cholesterol.
Weight Loss: Obese subjects advised to eat a Mediterranean diet lost no weight over four months compared to those advised to eat a strictly plant-based diet with no added fats who lost thirteen pounds.
Mediterranean Diet vs. Plant-Based Diet
Plant-Based Focus: The Mediterranean diet is primarily, but not exclusively, plant-based.
Provegetarian Scoring System: PREDIMED researchers created a “provegetarian” scoring system to test the effects of one’s dietary plant-to-animal ratio.
They found that moving along the spectrum toward more plants translated into a 40 percent lower risk of premature death.
Reversal of Heart Disease: The only diet that has ever been proven to reverse heart disease is a diet centered around whole plant foods.
The Lyon Diet Heart Study
Study Design: About six hundred individuals who had already had a heart attack were randomized into two groups. The control group received no dietary advice, while the experimental group was instructed to eat more of a Mediterranean-type diet, supplemented with a canola oil–based spread that would give them the plant-based omega-3s they would have normally gotten from foods like walnuts if they had actually lived on a Greek isle in the 1950s.
Dietary Changes: The Mediterranean group ate more breads and fruits, and less butter, cream, processed meat, and meat in general.
Heart Attack Reduction: The Mediterranean group went from having a 4 percent chance of having a heart attack each year down to just 1 percent.
Limitations and Criticisms
Despite the positive research, there are some limitations and criticisms of the Mediterranean diet.
Scoring Systems: Different studies have used a variety of scoring systems, making it difficult to compare results.
Study Bias: Most studies on the Mediterranean diet have been publicly funded but there have been accusations of a conspiracy of vested Big Fat commercial interests.
Misrepresentation: Many restaurants misrepresent the diet. For example, "Italian restaurants brag about the healthy Mediterranean diet, they serve a travesty of it".
Not Enough: While the Mediterranean diet results in less death and disease, the diet is not ideal because it may continue to feed heart disease. Ideally, we would want a diet that could stop or even reverse heart disease.
Practical Considerations
It's important to note that very few people actually follow the traditional Mediterranean diet. In fact, the prevalence of coronary heart disease skyrocketed by an order of magnitude within a few decades in Crete, blamed on the increased consumption of meat and cheese at the expense of plant foods. However, there are ways to incorporate Mediterranean principles into your own diet.
Focus on Whole Plant Foods: Emphasize fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes.
Reduce Meat and Dairy: Limit your consumption of red meat and high-fat dairy products.
Olive Oil as Main Fat Source: Use olive oil as your primary source of fat.
Increase Plant-to-Animal Ratio: Consider moving along the spectrum toward more plants and less animal products.
Plant-Based Diet: Eating a diet centered around whole plant foods has been proven to reverse heart disease in the majority of patients.
Enjoy Your Food: The Mediterranean diet isn't about restriction; it's about enjoying fresh, whole foods in a social setting.
Conclusion
The Mediterranean diet offers a delicious and effective approach to promoting heart health. By emphasizing plant-based foods, healthy fats, and moderate amounts of animal products, this dietary pattern can reduce the risk of heart disease, improve overall health, and potentially extend lifespan. While it may not be the only path to a healthy heart, the Mediterranean diet provides a compelling model for how diet can be a powerful tool for disease prevention and overall well-being. It is important to consider that the benefits of the Mediterranean diet seem to come from the plant-based foods, and that a more strictly plant-based diet, with no added fats, may be even more effective.
References
Greger, M., & Stone, G. (2015). How not to die: Discover the foods scientifically proven to prevent and reverse disease. Flatiron Books.
Greger, M. (2023). How not to age: The scientific approach to getting healthier as you get older. Flatiron Books.
Comments